Best Italian Restaurants in the East Village: Five Picks
Dana Whitfield · November 10, 2026 · 8 min
Lil’ Frankie’s at 19 1st Avenue lists restaurant hours to 4am on Friday and Saturday, and John’s of 12th Street at 302 East 12th Street prints “Established 1908”: two of the five best Italian restaurants in the East Village. The others are Olio e Più at 106 3rd Avenue, with a $29 weekday lunch menu, Fiaschetteria Pistoia at 647 East 11th Street, which books by phone only, and Gnocco at 337 East 10th Street, which cooks Emilia-Romagna pasta in an indoor garden. Everything below was read from each restaurant’s own site in October 2026.
Five picks compared by booking and cost for two
| Restaurant | Address | Best for | Books by | Cost for two |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fiaschetteria Pistoia | 647 East 11th Street, at Avenue C | A Tuscan dinner | Phone only | 71, in the menu’s bare numbers |
| John’s of 12th Street | 302 East 12th Street | Red sauce, or a party of 20 or more | Phone, after 3PM | 79.85 dollars |
| Olio e Più | 106 3rd Avenue | A weekday lunch set menu | Resy | 58 dollars at lunch, 67 at dinner |
| Gnocco | 337 East 10th Street | Emilia-Romagna pasta | Online prompt or phone | No dinner prices in page text |
| Lil’ Frankie’s | 19 1st Avenue | A table after midnight | Resy or phone | No prices in page text |
What each pick needed to qualify
Each pick has an East Village address, a live official site and hours printed as text. “Best” labels the main reason to go and is not a rank. Cost for two sums named dishes at the menu’s own prices, before drinks, tax and tip, and a menu with no readable prices gets no total. Nobody from this publication visited or phoned any restaurant here.
Best for a Tuscan dinner by phone: Fiaschetteria Pistoia
Pistoia’s East Village room is at 647 East 11th Street and Avenue C, and its home page describes “traditional Tuscan Cuisine.” Antipasti run from 18 to 22 and pastas from 24 to 36, printed as bare numbers with no currency sign, so confirm prices by phone. This site’s one-pick-per-area guide names Pistoia as its East Village pick, on two pastas at 48.
What to order: the Crostini Toscani (19), with chicken liver sauce, then the Maccheroni sull’Anatra (28), homemade pasta with slow-cooked duck ragù.
Cost for two: 71 in the menu’s bare numbers, for Crostini Toscani (19), Pappardelle al Ragù (24) and Maccheroni sull’Anatra (28).
Booking: phone only. The Reservations page says “WE DO NOT ACCEPT RESERVATIONS BY EMAIL OR SOCIAL MEDIA” and lists +1 (212) 777-3355 for the East Village; only the West Village line is labeled “FIRST COME FIRST SERVE.” As of October 2026 the Contact page lists “EVERY DAY: 5:30pm – 10:30pm.” The menu adds a one-dish-per-person minimum and a 22% to 25% gratuity for parties of 5 or more.
Best for red sauce since 1908: John’s of 12th Street
John’s prints “Established 1908” on its home page, and the sister site’s guide to the oldest Italian restaurants in NYC covers that tradition. Two menu sections set the range: Pasta from $11.95 for butter sauce to $24.95 for Carbonara and Spaghetti with Meatballs, and Specialties of the House from $27.95 to $34.95. The Menus page opens with a takeout and delivery notice, so confirm dine-in prices when you call.
What to order: the Tuscan Ragu over Homemade Pappardelle ($34.95), which the menu flags as “Featured on Diners, Drive-Ins & Dives,” or the Baked Homemade Lasagna ($27.95).
Cost for two: 79.85 dollars for Mozzarella, Basil & Tomatoes ($16.95), the lasagna and the Tuscan Ragu. Staying in the Pasta section, the same starter with Homemade Manicotti ($19.95) and Spaghetti with Meatballs ($24.95) comes to 61.85 dollars.
Booking: by phone. The Hours page says “RESERVATIONS CAN BE MADE BY CALLING US AFTER 3PM” at 212-475-9531 and mentions no online booking. As of October 2026 it lists 4-10PM Sunday to Wednesday and 4-10:30PM Thursday to Saturday; the Menus page gives 4-10PM for takeout and delivery, so confirm the closing time. Party bookings carry a 20-person minimum and the back room “can host 70 guests.” Its vegan menu is covered in this site’s guide to vegetarian and vegan Italian menus.
Best for a weekday lunch set menu: Olio e Più
Olio e Più East Village lists a Lunch Prix Fixe at $29, Monday to Friday, 11am to 4pm, with three starters and three mains, among them spaghetti alla carbonara and polpette della nonna. It is for regular dining only, not private events or group bookings. At dinner the eight handmade pastas span $23 (Ricotta Gnocchi al Pesto) to $32 (Short Rib Pappardelle). The group prints a menu page for each room, and prices differ by room: the Greenwich Village page lists the same carbonara at $29.
What to order: the Spaghetti alla Carbonara ($26), which is also one of the three lunch mains.
Cost for two: 58 dollars for two lunch prix fixe menus, or 67 dollars at dinner for Truffle Arancini ($17), Spaghetti alla Carbonara and Lasagnetta Classica ($24). The set lunch is 9 dollars less than that dinner order.
Booking: the Reservations page sends bookings to Resy and states “Cash and all major credit cards are accepted.” As of October 2026, hours run to midnight Sunday to Thursday and 1am Friday and Saturday, with the note “*Kitchen hours might differ.” Its East Village events page lists 50 seated on the first floor, 44 on the second and 18 on the terrace, with a link for parties of 15 or more.
Best for Emilia-Romagna pasta in an indoor garden: Gnocco
Gnocco, at 337 East 10th Street, has been open since 2000 and says its menu “celebrates Emilia-Romagna and the Giovanetti family’s roots in Modena, Italy.”
What to order: the signature gnocco fritto, which the site calls “pillowy fried dough with cured meats and cheeses,” then the handmade tagliatelle al ragù.
Cost for two: the Menu page’s readable text lists no dishes or prices, so no dinner total can be built. The posted brunch price is $49.99 per person for one main dish and unlimited drinks for 1.5 hours, which is 99.98 dollars for two, tax and gratuity extra, Saturday and Sunday from 11am to 4pm.
Booking: the Reservations page shows an online reservation prompt and gives (212) 677-1913 for phone bookings. The hours block prints “Tuesday Thursday 2pm - 10pm” with no Wednesday line, so confirm midweek hours.
Best for a table after midnight: Lil’ Frankie’s
Lil’ Frankie’s “Restaurant Hours” run from 11 am daily to 2 am Sunday to Thursday and 4 am Friday and Saturday, as of October 2026. The site does not say when the kitchen stops. Its Dinner page links to a menu with no readable prices, and its Specials page prints a “Today’s Specials” list for a single day, so no cost for two is given here.
What to order: the home page captions its photographs “Mezze Rigatoni Ragu with Baby Meatballs and Ricotta di Pecora Cheese” and “Pizza Norcina with Red Onions, Mushrooms and Wild Fennel Sausage.”
Booking: the Reservations page points to Resy, and the site header prints “Call 212-420-0040.” A “Cash Only” line closes the Specials page; whether it applies to the whole restaurant is not stated, so confirm payment before going.
Open late: who closes when
Of the five, only Lil’ Frankie’s lists a close past 1am. Olio e Più reaches midnight, or 1am Friday and Saturday, with a kitchen caveat, and Pistoia, John’s and Gnocco all stop at 10pm or 10:30pm. Two other rooms run late. Frank, listed under “The Family” on Lil’ Frankie’s site, is at 88 2nd Avenue and closes at 12 am, or 1 am Friday and Saturday. Nuovo York Pizza is a pizza shop, not a trattoria, at 105 East 9th Street between 3rd and 4th Avenues, listing 11AM to 3AM Monday to Thursday and Sunday and to 4:30AM Friday and Saturday. This site’s after-10pm guide covers other neighborhoods; none of these five appears in it.
How far ahead do East Village tables book?
None of the five publishes a booking window, a wait time or a walk-in rule on the pages read, so lead time is unknown; the table above shows how each one takes bookings.
Frequently asked questions
What are the best Italian restaurants in the East Village?
Fiaschetteria Pistoia at 647 East 11th Street suits a Tuscan dinner booked by phone, John’s of 12th Street at 302 East 12th Street suits red sauce, established in 1908, and Olio e Più at 106 3rd Avenue has a $29 weekday lunch set menu. Gnocco at 337 East 10th Street and Lil’ Frankie’s at 19 1st Avenue complete the five.
Where can you eat Italian in the East Village after midnight?
Lil’ Frankie’s at 19 1st Avenue lists restaurant hours to 2 am Sunday to Thursday and 4 am Friday and Saturday, as of October 2026, and its site does not say when the kitchen stops. Olio e Più at 106 3rd Avenue lists midnight, or 1am Friday and Saturday, and notes that kitchen hours might differ. Call either one to confirm the last order.
How much does dinner for two cost at an East Village Italian restaurant?
On menus read in October 2026, a shared starter and two pastas or mains cost 67 dollars at Olio e Più and 79.85 dollars at John’s of 12th Street, or 61.85 dollars there with two pastas, before drinks, tax and tip. Fiaschetteria Pistoia’s equivalent order totals 71 in bare numbers with no currency sign, so confirm by phone. Gnocco’s and Lil’ Frankie’s dinner menus are not readable as text, so no total is built for them.
Which East Village Italian restaurant suits a large group?
John’s of 12th Street says its back room “can host 70 guests,” without saying seated or standing, and sets a 20-person minimum for party bookings. Olio e Più’s East Village events page lists 50 seated on the first floor, 44 on the second and 18 on the terrace. Gnocco says full buyout options are available. All as of October 2026; confirm capacities directly.