Chapter · Nov 17

Best Italian Restaurants in SoHo and Nolita: Five Picks

Dana Whitfield · November 17, 2026 · 8 min

The short answerBest Italian restaurants in SoHo and Nolita: Torrisi, Rubirosa, La Pecora Bianca, Piccola Cucina and Il Corallo, with hours, booking rules and cost for two.

Among the best Italian restaurants in SoHo and Nolita, Il Corallo Trattoria on Prince Street posts the lowest dinner floor, 48 dollars for an antipasto and the two cheapest pastas, against 64.85 at Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana on Spring Street and 70 at La Pecora Bianca on Prince Street. On Mulberry Street, Torrisi opens dining-room tables 30 days ahead for parties of up to 6 and Rubirosa takes reservations 7 days ahead, the only two booking windows printed among the five. Every hour, price and booking rule below is from the restaurants’ own websites, as of October 2026.

Booking window, hours and price floor

Restaurant Address Booking window Hours Floor for two
Torrisi 275 Mulberry Street, Nolita 30 days, parties of up to 6; bar walk-ins Dinner 5:00pm to 11:00pm, Monday to Saturday No dish prices in page text
Rubirosa 235 Mulberry Street 7 days; space held for walk-ins 11AM to 11PM daily No dollar prices printed
La Pecora Bianca (SoHo) 54 Prince Street None printed; online form From 10:00am weekends, 11:30am weekdays 70 dollars
Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana 196 Spring Street None printed 11:30 AM to 11:00 PM daily 64.85 dollars
Il Corallo Trattoria 176 Prince Street None printed; Resy 12 pm to 9 pm, 10 pm Friday and Saturday 48 dollars

Who calls itself SoHo, and how the floor is counted

The labels follow each restaurant’s own site: Torrisi says Nolita, while La Pecora Bianca, Piccola Cucina and Il Corallo say SoHo. Rubirosa names neither and is placed by its Mulberry Street address. Each also prints hours as text and a way to book. The floor is the cheapest item under a menu’s antipasti or appetizers heading plus its two cheapest pastas, before drinks, tax and tip; a menu with no printed dish prices gets none. This publication did not visit or phone any of them. For Little Italy proper, see The Red Sauce Index’s list of Little Italy restaurants.

Which Mulberry Street Italian restaurants book ahead?

The two Mulberry Street rooms split on party size: Torrisi’s window covers up to 6, and Rubirosa sends 8 or more to a form.

Torrisi, Mulberry Street: a 30-day window and a bar for walk-ins

Torrisi, at 275 Mulberry Street, describes itself as “housed within the iconic Puck Building on Mulberry Street, right in the heart of Nolita.” As of October 2026 it lists dinner from 5:00pm to 11:00pm Monday to Saturday and lunch from 11:30am to 2:00pm Wednesday to Saturday, with no Sunday hours.

Floor for two: none computed. The page’s menu tabs, from dinner to cocktails, show no dishes or prices in its text.

Booking: “Reservations for the dining room at Torrisi are available 30 days in advance for parties of up to 6 guests exclusively on Resy,” and it “takes walk-ins on a first come, first served basis at our Bar Counter.” The page also names Dorsia, a members-only platform. Its corkage fee is $110 per 750ml bottle ($190 for a magnum); this site’s guide to NYC corkage fees at Italian restaurants covers other rooms.

Rubirosa, Mulberry Street: open 11AM to 11PM, groups of 8 to 22

Rubirosa, at 235 Mulberry Street, lists “Monday-Sunday 11AM - 11PM” and says it is open 7 days a week. Its Menus page lists dishes without dollar prices, so no cost for two can be computed, though it sizes the pizzas: the large 18-inch “serves 2-3.”

Order: the Roman Cacio e Pepe, or on Sundays the “Sunday Sauce (Sundays Only)” of braciole, meatball, pork sausage and braised ribs over spaghetti or lumache.

Booking: its Reservations page says “We take reservations 7 days in advance via Resy, over the phone” and “We save space for walk-ins every day,” and walk-ins check in with the hosts. The phone is (212) 965-0500; groups of 8 to 22 guests for a family-style lunch or dinner use the Group Dining form.

Which SoHo Italian restaurants open earliest and cost least?

Among the three SoHo picks, La Pecora Bianca opens earliest on weekends, Piccola Cucina closes latest and Il Corallo has the lowest bill.

La Pecora Bianca, Prince Street: weekends from 10:00am

La Pecora Bianca’s SoHo room is at 54 Prince Street. As of October 2026 it opens at 11:30am Monday to Friday and 10:00am on weekends, and closes at 10:00pm Monday to Wednesday, 10:30pm Thursday to Saturday and 9:30pm Sunday.

Order: the Tagliatelle with beef and pork bolognese ($29), and for a pair the Tiramisu for Two ($19).

Floor for two: 70 dollars for Whipped Ricotta ($17), Spaghetti with pomodoro or cacio e pepe ($25) and Rigatoni with vodka sauce and stracciatella ($28). The Local Burrata ($21) in place of the ricotta makes it 74.

Booking: a Reservations form on the site, which offers party sizes from 1 to 8+, or (212) 380-8202. The private events page lists the main dining room for parties of up to 12.

Piccola Cucina, Spring Street: Sicilian pasta until 11:00 PM

The Osteria, at 196 Spring Street, says “We are in the heart of Soho” and lists 11:30 AM to 11:00 PM, Monday to Sunday. Pastas run from $22.95 for the Maccheroni alla Norma to $28.95 for the Busiate. A special lunch is $16.95, Monday to Friday, 11:30 AM to 4:00 PM; the page does not say what it includes.

Order: the Paccheri alla Nerano ($24.95), with zucchini and provolone.

Floor for two: 64.85 dollars for the Zuppa del giorno ($16.95), Maccheroni alla Norma ($22.95) and Paccheri alla Nerano ($24.95). The Burrata con pomodorini e rucola ($20.95) in place of the soup makes it 68.85.

Booking: the group’s Book a table page or (646) 478 7488. That page sends larger parties and event requests to an email address or a contact form, with a cutoff of 6 or 8 guests depending on the restaurant, so confirm the Osteria’s.

Il Corallo, Prince Street: the 48-dollar floor

Il Corallo, at 176 Prince Street, says it “has been part of SoHo since 1992” and lists 12 pm to 9 pm Sunday to Thursday and 12 pm to 10 pm on Friday and Saturday. Its Pasta della Casa list runs from $20 to $24. The pages carry a 2024 footer, so confirm prices.

Order: the Spaghetti Carbonara ($20), listed with pancetta and a fresh raw egg yolk.

Floor for two: 48 dollars for the Zuppa del giorno ($8) and two $20 pastas, the Spaghetti Carbonara and the Rigatoni Padani. The Burrata ($16) in place of the soup makes it 56. A separate Piccolo Piatti list prints four plates at $6 each; counted as the starter, the floor would be 46 dollars.

Booking: Resy. The reservations page says “We seat complete parties only. Reservations are held for 15minutes before being released to the wait list.” Groups of up to 16 go through an email to the reservation team; calls and texts go to 212-941-7119.

Which SoHo and Nolita Italian restaurants take walk-ins?

Two of the five print a walk-in rule: Torrisi holds its Bar Counter for walk-ins, first come, first served, and Rubirosa says it saves space for them every day. The other three print neither a walk-in rule nor a window: Il Corallo books on Resy, La Pecora Bianca through a form and Piccola Cucina through a Book a table page, so call first.

One more Mulberry Street address, Parm at 248 Mulberry Street, says it “accepts reservations for up to 6 people via Resy and also welcomes walk-ins,” and is open 11am to 10pm daily. Its menu page prints one dollar figure, the $25 lunch special, so it is a fallback, not a sixth pick. This site’s guide to Italian in Manhattan without a reservation lists other rooms that print a walk-in policy.

How do the dinner floors and lunch specials compare?

On menus read in October 2026, the floors run 22 dollars apart, from 48 at Il Corallo to 70 at La Pecora Bianca. Soup is the cheapest antipasto at Il Corallo and Piccola Cucina, so the burrata all three list is the closer comparison: $16, $20.95 and $21, for totals of 56, 68.85 and 74 dollars, an 18-dollar spread.

Lunch specials total less: two come to 33.90 dollars at Il Corallo (daily, 12:00 pm to 4:00 pm) and at Piccola Cucina (weekdays, 11:30 AM to 4:00 PM; that page does not say what the special includes), and 50 dollars at Parm’s $25 special (daily, 11am to 3pm). For one pick in each of six other Manhattan areas, see this site’s one-pick-per-area guide.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Italian restaurant in SoHo?

Each of the three SoHo picks leads on one thing. Il Corallo Trattoria at 176 Prince Street has the lowest floor, 48 dollars, Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana at 196 Spring Street lists 11:30 AM to 11:00 PM daily, and La Pecora Bianca at 54 Prince Street opens at 10:00am on weekends.

Are there good Italian restaurants in Nolita?

Yes: Torrisi at 275 Mulberry Street, which calls itself “right in the heart of Nolita,” and Rubirosa at 235 Mulberry Street, which names no neighborhood, are the two Mulberry Street picks here. Torrisi opens dining-room tables 30 days ahead for parties of up to 6, and Rubirosa says it takes reservations 7 days in advance and is open 11AM to 11PM daily.

Where can a group of 8 or more eat Italian in SoHo and Nolita?

Rubirosa at 235 Mulberry Street takes groups of 8 to 22 for a family-style lunch or dinner through its Group Dining form. Il Corallo Trattoria at 176 Prince Street lists groups of up to 16 by email, and La Pecora Bianca at 54 Prince Street lists its main dining room for parties of up to 12. Torrisi’s dining-room window and Parm’s Resy bookings stop at 6 guests, so ask either about a larger table.

How expensive are Italian restaurants in SoHo?

On menus read in October 2026, dinner for two starts at 48 dollars at Il Corallo Trattoria, counting the cheapest antipasto and the two cheapest pastas. Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana comes to 64.85 and La Pecora Bianca to 70, before drinks, tax and tip. Torrisi and Rubirosa print no readable dinner prices.

↑ Table of chapters

Join the Grand Tour

New chapters land a few times a month — neighborhood maps, eating itineraries, and vetting intel for your next trip to the table.

Free passage · disembark any time