Chapter · Nov 14

Best Italian Restaurants in Greenwich Village: Six Picks

Dana Whitfield · November 14, 2026 · 8 min

The short answerBest Italian restaurants in Greenwich Village: six picks with a dish to order, cost for two from posted prices, late hours and each booking rule.

Six Italian restaurants in Greenwich Village suit six kinds of night: Il Mulino at 86 West Third Street for a Sunday dinner from 4pm, Babbo at 110 Waverly Place for a $115 tasting menu, and La Lanterna di Vittorio at 129 MacDougal Street for a table until 2am on Friday and Saturday. Olio e Più at 3 Greenwich Avenue runs a $29 weekday lunch menu, Da Andrea at 35 West 13th Street says walk-ins are welcome when tables are available, and Carbone at 181 Thompson Street publishes a dress code. All hours, prices and policies below are from the restaurants’ own sites, read in October 2026.

Six Greenwich Village picks, one line each

Restaurant Address Best for Saturday close Cost for two
Babbo 110 Waverly Place A set-price dinner, $115 per person 11pm 230 dollars for two Tour Tastings
Olio e Più 3 Greenwich Avenue A weekday lunch, $29 12am 58 dollars at lunch
La Lanterna di Vittorio 129 MacDougal Street A late table 2am 55 dollars for two lasagna flights
Da Andrea 35 West 13th Street Handmade pasta, walk-ins welcome 11pm 78 dollars
Il Mulino 86 West Third Street A Sunday dinner from 4pm 11pm No dish prices in page text
Carbone 181 Thompson Street A dressed-up dinner 11:30pm No dish prices in page text

What put these six on the list

Five of the six sites call their own room Greenwich Village; Carbone’s page prints only its Thompson Street address, so that label is this guide’s. Each has a live official site with hours printed as text. “Best” here names the main reason to go; no source ranks these six. Where a page prints dish prices, cost for two is the sum of named dishes before drinks, tax and tip; where it prints none, the entry says so. Nobody from this publication visited or phoned these restaurants.

Babbo: the $115 Tour Tasting

Babbo’s About text opens with a return to its “historic Greenwich Village carriage house” and dates the restaurant “Since 1998.” As of October 2026 the site lists dinner hours only: 5 to 10pm Sunday to Thursday and 5 to 11pm on Friday and Saturday. The Tour Tasting is “Seven plates in four courses $115 per person,” with two pastas served family-style and a $10 supplement for the Lobster Fusilloni.

What to order: the Lasagna alla Piastra ($35), listed with three meat ragù and parmigiano crema.

Cost for two: 230 dollars for two Tour Tastings, before supplements and drinks. À la carte, the Burrata ($27), Pappardelle alla Bolognese ($34) and Lasagna alla Piastra ($35) come to 96 dollars.

Booking: a Book A Table button and a phone line, (212) 777-0303. For groups the page says “please contact us directly.” This site’s one-pick-per-area guide also names Babbo.

Olio e Più: the $29 weekday lunch

Olio e Più’s Greenwich Village page describes a 74-seat restaurant, first opened in the summer of 2010, where Sixth and Greenwich Avenues meet Christopher Street. The group prints a menu page per New York room (Greenwich Village, Bryant Park, East Village), and every price here is from the Greenwich Village page; the East Village page lists the same Butternut Squash Ravioli at $25. As of October 2026 the Lunch Prix Fixe is $29, Monday to Friday, 11am to 4pm, a starter and a main course, and it does not apply to group bookings. Hours run 11am to 12am Monday to Friday and 10am to 12am on weekends, with the note “*Kitchen hours might differ.”

What to order: the Butternut Squash Ravioli ($28), with amaretti biscuit, brown butter and sage.

Cost for two: 58 dollars for two lunch menus. At dinner, Bruschetta Tricolore ($19), Tagliatelle, Lemon & Burrata ($26) and Lasagnetta Classica ($26) come to 71 dollars.

Booking: the reservation form offers party sizes from 1 Person to 8+ People, and the phone line is +1 (212) 243-6546.

La Lanterna di Vittorio: open to 2am on weekends

La Lanterna says it opened in 1977. As of October 2026 the home page lists 10am to 1am Sunday to Thursday and 10am to 2am on Friday and Saturday. The menu leads with “Le Lasagne di Nonno Vittorio (World Famous Lasagnas),” every one at $25.50, plus a $27.50 Lasagna Flight.

What to order: the Lasagna Flight ($27.50), which the home page pitches as four classics on one plate, in a Carne, Vegetariano or Mare e Monti set.

Cost for two: 55 dollars for two flights. A shared Caprese ($15.00) makes it 70 dollars.

Booking: a “book a table” button and (917)-639-3236. Its glass-enclosed garden and cozy dining rooms are “each perfect for parties of thirteen or more,” with a separate large-group link.

Da Andrea: handmade pasta and a printed walk-in line

Da Andrea’s FAQ places the Greenwich Village room at 35 West 13th Street between Fifth and Sixth Avenues and says “Fresh, handmade pasta is at the heart of our menu and is prepared in-house daily.” As of October 2026 its location page lists Monday to Thursday 11:30am to 10pm, Friday 11:30am to 11pm, Saturday 11am to 11pm and Sunday 11am to 10pm. The dinner menu has eleven pastas, from $29 to $36.

What to order: the Spaghetti Alla Carbonara ($30), with pancetta, pecorino and egg yolk.

Cost for two: 78 dollars for Insalata Di Cesare ($20), Gnocchetti Di Patate ($29) and Pennette Con Melanzane ($29).

Booking: the FAQ, written for both Da Andrea rooms, says “We recommend reservations, especially for dinner and on weekends. Walk-ins are welcome when tables are available.” The Greenwich Village phone line is (212) 367-1979. The large-group page, also shared, asks for a credit card for groups of up to 25 and a 25% non-refundable deposit for 26 to 30.

Il Mulino: Sunday dinner from 4pm

Il Mulino’s Downtown page calls the West Third Street room its “flagship restaurant in Greenwich Village.” As of October 2026 it lists Monday to Friday 5:00PM to 10:30PM, Saturday 5:00PM to 11:00PM and Sunday 4:00PM to 9:00PM, so Sunday dinner starts an hour before Babbo’s or Carbone’s and ends first of the six, at 9pm. The pages read link no menu and print no dishes or prices, only “exquisite handmade pastas” and “an expansive aperitivo at the bar.”

What to order, cost for two: the pages read name no dish and print no price, so no total can be built.

Booking: “Call us : 212 673 3783” or “Book your table from our site.” For business lunches and corporate events, the Biz Lunch page says the dining room “can accommodate parties of 15 to 85 guests.”

Carbone: a dress code and no posted prices

Carbone, at 181 Thompson Street between Bleecker and Houston, lists lunch Tuesday to Sunday, 11:30am to 2:00pm, and dinner every day from 5:00pm to 11:30pm as of October 2026. Its dress code bars shorts, open-toed shoes and tank tops, and a guest who does not appear “sufficiently well-presented may be refused entry.”

What to order, cost for two: the page text shows no dish or price, because the menu sits behind a “Select a Menu” prompt, so no total can be built.

Booking: reservations can be made “directly through our website, authorized reservation platforms, or by contacting our restaurant teams via email.” Large-party reservations run “for groups up to 18.”

Which Greenwich Village Italian restaurants are open late?

Two of the six close at midnight or later on Saturday: La Lanterna di Vittorio at 2am and Olio e Più at 12am. Carbone closes at 11:30pm, and Babbo, Da Andrea and Il Mulino at 11pm. La Lanterna lists 1am Sunday to Thursday. None of the six publishes a last-order time on the pages read, so call before a late arrival. For a later table in another neighborhood, this site’s East Village guide covers Lil’ Frankie’s, whose site lists restaurant hours to 4am on Friday and Saturday.

Which Greenwich Village Italian restaurant takes walk-ins?

Only Da Andrea prints a walk-in line, and its FAQ covers both Da Andrea rooms. The other five state no walk-in rule on the pages read, and none of the six publishes how far ahead tables open or how long a wait runs. Without a booking, Da Andrea is the one printed starting point; confirm its hours by phone on the day.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best Italian restaurant in Greenwich Village?

No published fact ranks the six, so the answer depends on the night. Babbo at 110 Waverly Place suits a set-price dinner at $115 per person, Olio e Più at 3 Greenwich Avenue suits a weekday lunch at $29, and La Lanterna di Vittorio at 129 MacDougal Street suits a late table.

Which Greenwich Village Italian restaurant costs least for two?

On menus read in October 2026, the two cheapest pasta dishes cost 51 dollars at La Lanterna di Vittorio (two lasagne at $25.50), 52 at Olio e Più and 58 at both Babbo and Da Andrea, a 7-dollar spread before drinks, tax and tip. Olio e Più’s weekday lunch is also 58 dollars for two, a starter and a main each. Il Mulino and Carbone publish no dish prices on the pages read.

Is there a prix fixe lunch at a Greenwich Village Italian restaurant?

Olio e Più at 3 Greenwich Avenue lists a Lunch Prix Fixe at $29, Monday to Friday, 11am to 4pm, as of October 2026: a starter and a main course, not available for group bookings. Carbone at 181 Thompson Street lists lunch Tuesday to Sunday, 11:30am to 2:00pm, but its page text shows no prices.

What is the difference between Greenwich Village and the West Village for dinner?

No restaurant site read here defines the boundary, so five of the six picks follow their own sites’ Greenwich Village wording. The labels meet on Greenwich Avenue: Olio e Più at 3 Greenwich Avenue calls itself a Greenwich Village restaurant, while this site’s West Village guide places Rosemary’s (18 Greenwich Avenue) and Don Angie (103) in the West Village. The two lists share no restaurant.

↑ Table of chapters

Join the Grand Tour

New chapters land a few times a month — neighborhood maps, eating itineraries, and vetting intel for your next trip to the table.

Free passage · disembark any time