Vegan Pizza in NYC: Pizzerias That Publish a Vegan Menu
Dana Whitfield · November 3, 2026 · 8 min
Seven New York spots publish a vegan pizza or a written vegan-cheese swap on their own websites: Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop, Two Boots, Fumo, Tufino, Prince Street Pizza, Artistic Pizza and Rubirosa. Of the seven, Two Boots and Fumo name Daiya as their vegan cheese, Paulie Gee’s names Numu, and only Tufino prints one charge, $3.00, for making any pizza vegan. Menus, hours and prices below come from each restaurant’s own website, checked in October 2026.
Vegan pizza in NYC at a glance, as of October 2026
Prices appear only where a page prints one, and a figure with no currency sign is marked to confirm.
| Restaurant | Address | Best for | The vegan detail on its site |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop | 110 Franklin Street, Greenpoint; 100 1st Avenue, East Village | A named vegan mozzarella | Four vegan pies at Greenpoint, Numu mozzarella on three; no gluten-free pizza |
| Two Boots | 101 7th Avenue South, West Village | The longest vegan list | Eight vegan pizzas and a vegan calzone; Daiya on seven pies |
| Fumo (Upper West Side) | 2791 Broadway | A labelled, priced vegan pizza | A pizza named Vegan, with Daiya cheese, $21 |
| Tufino Pizzeria Napoletana | 36-08 Ditmars Boulevard, Astoria | A priced vegan swap | Any pizza vegan or gluten-free for $3.00 |
| Prince Street Pizza | 27 Prince Street, SoHo | A vegan Sicilian square | “The vegan” with vegan cheese, marked available gluten-free |
| Artistic Pizza | 123 W 3rd Street | Vegan pies after midnight | Open to 2am Sunday to Thursday, 4am Friday and Saturday |
| Rubirosa | 235 Mulberry Street | A written cheese swap at an Italian restaurant | Written vegan-cheese swap, two sauces excluded |
How these seven were picked
A place made the list only if its own site names a specific vegan pie or a written vegan-cheese swap for pizza. Reviews, delivery apps and social posts were left out, so three names sit in notes below instead of in the table. Nobody from this publication visited or phoned any of them. A vegan label is not an allergen guarantee: confirm the cheese, whether vegan pies share ovens and prep surfaces with dairy pies, and any nut or dairy allergy with the restaurant when you order.
Which pizzerias list vegan pies by name?
Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop: best for a named vegan mozzarella
The Greenpoint shop lists four vegan pies: Vegan Cheese, built on tomato sauce and Numu vegan mozzarella; Vegan Pepperoni; Vegan Vidalia Square, with Follow Your Heart vegan parm; and Vegan Freddy Prinze, which adds Be-Hive vegan sausage. Its FAQ says vegan pies and slices come round and square; the East Village page repeats that and lists a Vegan Vidalia. Both pages say the shop does not offer gluten-free pizza.
Cost: confirm. The Greenpoint page prints 28 beside the dairy Cheese pie and 40 beside Vegan Cheese, and the East Village page prints 40.25 beside Vegan Vidalia, all without a currency sign or a per-slice or per-pie label. The East Village page also prints its hours as opening at 11:30pm, so check them first.
Hours: Greenpoint runs 11:30am to 10pm Sunday to Thursday and to 1am Friday and Saturday; its page says it takes no phone orders.
Two Boots: best for the longest vegan list
The menu page has a Vegan Pizzas section with eight pies, from V for Vegan to Vegan Mr. Pink, plus a vegan calzone. Seven of the eight name Daiya non-dairy cheese; Earth Mother is marinara and vegetables with no cheese listed. Its FAQ says a local vegan food vendor partners on a pie of the month every November, and that the gluten-free crust, which can take any menu ingredient, is not suitable for true celiacs.
Cost: where a vegan pie’s pop-up on the menu page prints bare size-and-price figures, it sits under an East Village heading, a shop the locations page lists as Coming Soon, so confirm West Village prices. Hours: the locations page lists the West Village shop open to 3am Friday and Saturday.
Prince Street Pizza: best for a vegan Sicilian square
The menu lists “the vegan” among its Sicilian squares: sweet marinara, vegan cheese, fresh basil and olive oil, marked available in gluten-free. The menu page prints no cheese brand or price. Squares come by the slice or as an eight-slice whole pie; the FAQ says slices are an in-store order only and phone orders are whole pies.
Artistic Pizza: best for vegan pies late at night
Artistic Pizza names an Artistic Vegan Beyond Pepperoni and The Vegan Margherita Pie on its home page, and its FAQ adds a ZEROGluten Vegan Hawaii Luau Pizza to the vegan and gluten-free options. The home page prints no menu or prices and sends orders to an outside ordering page, so ask the shop about cheese and cost.
Which Italian restaurants swap in vegan cheese?
Three of the seven are Italian restaurants that put a vegan-cheese option in writing.
Fumo, Upper West Side: best for a labelled, priced vegan pizza
Fumo’s Upper West Side menu, for 2791 Broadway, lists a pizza named Vegan, with Daiya cheese, cashew basil pesto and crushed plum tomato, at $21 and tagged “vegan” in both of its pizza lists. The Grandma Pizza carries its own line, “Gluten free or cauliflower crust $3 / sub vegan cheese $3.” Because that pesto is cashew basil, ask about nuts before ordering.
Tufino Pizzeria Napoletana: best for a priced swap
The pizza list says “Make any pizza vegan OR gluten-free for $3.00,” and the extra-topping lists put vegan cheese and vegan pepperoni at +$3.00 and vegan sausage and vegan meatball at +$4.00. On the page’s own figures, the $19.00 Margherita made vegan comes to 22 dollars. The “OR” leaves open whether one pie can be both vegan and gluten-free, so ask. The same menu page lists five non-pizza dishes under a Vegan heading, and the only vegan cheese brand it names is Vio-life, on $14.00 vegan mozzarella sticks.
Rubirosa: a written swap with two sauces excluded
Rubirosa’s Menus page puts “we can substitute for vegan cheese” at the top of its pizza list, and its toppings note rules out pies made with the pesto or vodka sauce, which contain cheese. It names no cheese brand and lists no pizza prices. This site’s guide to vegetarian Italian restaurants in NYC has the exact wording and its note on eggs in the pastas.
Is NY Pizza Suprema a vegan option?
Not on the pages of its own site that were read. The NY Pizza Suprema menu page, for 413 8th Avenue, prints an address, a phone number and daily hours but lists no dishes, and its home, about, contact and press pages, read in October 2026, do not use the word vegan. Silence is not a yes: call (212) 594-8939 before making the trip.
What about Green Oven Pizza and Wild?
Green Oven Pizza, at 707 9th Avenue in Hell’s Kitchen, says on its home page “The Best Plant Based, Gluten Free Pizza in NY” and that it offers plant-based cheeses. The home page lists no dishes or menu prices, only ordering buttons, so it makes a claim with no named pie behind it and sits outside the list above.
Wild, at 535 Hudson Street, also sits outside the seven. Its menu page says the pizzas are handmade to create its “famous gluten-free vegan crust,” but on that page the word vegan is attached to no individual pizza. The vegetarian guide covers the dishes Wild does label vegan.
What is the best vegan pizza in New York?
The published menus support a match by need, not one winner.
- A named cheese brand: Two Boots or Fumo (Daiya), or Paulie Gee’s (Numu).
- A price before you go: Fumo’s $21 Vegan pizza, or Tufino, where a vegan Margherita is 22 dollars on the page’s figures.
- Gluten-free as well: Prince Street’s “the vegan,” Artistic’s ZEROGluten pie or Two Boots’ gluten-free crust. Paulie Gee’s says it has no gluten-free pizza.
- Late: Artistic to 2am or 4am, Two Boots’ West Village shop to 3am on Friday and Saturday, Paulie Gee’s Greenpoint to 1am those nights.
A gluten-free label is not a celiac guarantee; this site’s guide to gluten-free Italian restaurants in NYC lists what to ask. For delivery, the guide to which Italian dishes survive the trip home covers why a closed box softens a pizza crust and how to reheat a slice.
Frequently asked questions
Where can you get vegan pizza in NYC?
As of October 2026, seven restaurants publish a vegan pizza or a written vegan-cheese swap on their own sites: Paulie Gee’s Slice Shop, Two Boots, Fumo on the Upper West Side, Tufino in Astoria, Prince Street Pizza in SoHo, Artistic Pizza and Rubirosa. That is the set checked here, not every pizzeria in the city. Of these, Two Boots lists the most vegan pizzas, eight; Paulie Gee’s Greenpoint shop lists four.
Does NY Pizza Suprema have vegan pizza?
The pages of NY Pizza Suprema’s own site that were read in October 2026 (home, menu, about, contact and press) do not mention vegan food, and its menu page for 413 8th Avenue lists no dishes. That is silence, not a no, so call (212) 594-8939 and ask before you go.
Is there vegan cheese on pizza at Italian restaurants?
At some. Fumo’s Upper West Side menu lists a $21 Vegan pizza with Daiya cheese, Tufino charges $3.00 to make any pizza vegan or gluten-free, and Rubirosa says it can substitute vegan cheese on its pizzas except those with pesto or vodka sauce. Tufino and Rubirosa name no pizza cheese brand on their menu pages, so ask what the kitchen uses.
How much does vegan pizza cost in NYC?
Of the seven, Fumo prints $21 for its Vegan pizza, and Tufino charges $3.00 to make any pizza vegan, which takes its $19.00 Margherita to 22 dollars. Paulie Gee’s pages print bare numbers such as 40 beside Vegan Cheese that need confirming. The Prince Street, Rubirosa and Artistic pages print no pizza prices, and Two Boots’ vegan-pie figures sit under an East Village heading for a shop listed as coming soon.